Pay Less Notices: What a Subcontractor Should Check Before the Final Date
Can you ensure that I am paid the correct amount and on time?
It is one of the questions clients put to IMH, and the answer nearly always starts with the notices.
Under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, as amended, construction contracts falling within the statutory regime are subject to payment requirements built around due dates, final dates for payment and notices. The detail matters because the amount that has to be paid by the final date can turn on whether the required notices were served correctly and on time.
How the notices fit together
The contract should establish the payment mechanism and identify who is responsible for issuing the relevant notices.
A payment notice is normally required no later than five days after the payment due date. Depending on the contractual arrangement, the notice may be given by the payer, a specified person or the payee. It should state the sum considered due at the due date and the basis on which that sum has been calculated.
If the required payment notice is not given, the statutory and contractual machinery may allow the payee to give a notice establishing the notified sum instead.
Unless a valid Pay Less Notice alters the position, the notified sum is required to be paid by the final date for payment. The precise requirements and deadlines depend on the contract and, where applicable, the Scheme for Construction Contracts.
Where the contract fails to provide compliant payment machinery, provisions of the Scheme can apply.
What to check when a Pay Less Notice arrives
Was it in time?
Count the days using the contract actually entered into, including any amendments. Heavily amended subcontracts frequently alter the standard-form periods. A notice served outside the applicable period may not achieve the result the payer intended.
Does it show its working?
The statutory regime requires the Pay Less Notice to state both the sum the payer considers to be due and the basis on which that sum has been calculated. A bare figure with little or no explanation deserves careful examination.
Who sent it, and where?
Check the notice and communications provisions. They may prescribe who is authorised to issue notices, how they are served and where they must be sent. Compliance can be important to validity.
Is the deduction supported by an entitlement?
Delay costs, defect costs and other contra charges often appear within Pay Less Notices. Including a deduction within a notice does not, by itself, establish the underlying contractual entitlement to that deduction. The contractual and evidential basis should also be tested.
“We haven't been paid either” is not generally a defence
Section 113 of the Construction Act generally renders ineffective a provision making payment conditional upon the payer receiving payment from somebody further up the contractual chain, subject to the statutory insolvency exception and the scope of the Act.
A client's failure to pay may explain why a contractor has a cash-flow problem. It does not, without more, establish a defence to payment further down the chain.
If the money still does not arrive
Where the statutory requirements are satisfied, section 112 gives a party the right to suspend performance of some or all of its contractual obligations for qualifying non-payment after giving the required notice. The statutory consequences can include reasonable costs and expenses caused by the suspension and an adjustment to the period for completion.
Suspension is nevertheless a serious contractual step. Before taking it, the payment position, notice requirements and scope of the statutory right should be checked carefully.
A dispute arising under a construction contract to which the statutory adjudication regime applies may also be referred to adjudication. Section 108 provides for a decision within 28 days of referral, subject to the permitted extensions, and the decision is binding until the dispute is finally resolved by proceedings, arbitration where applicable, or agreement.
Where money goes missing before any notice is served
Not every payment shortfall starts with an aggressive Pay Less Notice.
Value can be lost earlier through late applications, insufficient measurement or inadequate records. On a run of fire safety remediation schemes, a principal contractor's applications were often late and thin on detail, and instructed variations were not being captured. IMH restructured the monthly cycle so applications were submitted on time, aligned with the contractual requirements and supported by measurement and a clear written narrative. Certified values rose significantly and payment disputes fell.
The statutory machinery may be technical, but successful payment management is largely about discipline. If a Payment Notice or Pay Less Notice has landed and the figure does not look right, speak to Ian Heavey before the relevant contractual deadlines pass.
Related reading: Case Study: Restoring Payment Certainty and IMH's Practice Areas
This article provides general commercial commentary and is not legal advice on a particular contract. The applicable legislation, contractual terms and amendments, and the particular facts should always be checked.